I received an advanced review copy of this book from the publisher.
My Review:
Uglow’s book is a comprehensive social history of Britain during the period of the Napoleonic Wars. She makes extensive use of letters, journals and diaries from different social strata; we are given a first hand account of life in early 19th century Britian from clergymen, farmers, bankers, soldiers, mill owners and aristocratic women. The only class from which we do not directly hear are obviously the illiterate poor. But that is not to say she excludes them entirely; we are given descriptions about workhouses, wandering homeless and bread shortages from the diaries of the middle and upper classes.
We do learn about the famous players in the wars like Pitt, Nelson, King George III, Wellington and Napoleon himself. But they are not the focus of this history. One will not find military battles, biographies of famous generals or copies of treaties in this book. But the reader will discover how the daily lives and routines of British citizens were affected by this prolonged and costly war.
Uglow’s chapters are organized by themes and topics that occupied British citizens at home while soldiers were elsewhere in the world fighting the French. At the beginning of the war, fear of invasion is a constant threat. In order to make themselves feel more secure, local towns formed their own militia and proudly did drill practices in case the enemy ever landed on their shores. We hear from coopers, bankers, shoemakers, farmers and men from all walks of life who were eagerly getting ready to defend their own borders from the likes of the French.
The themes of many of the chapters are related to money and economics. Banking, bread prices, the running of mills and the national debt were all affected by the wartime economy. Thousands of soldiers had to be given uniforms, shoes, and weapons. The government had to pay for all of these supplies so taxes were constantly being raised. The farmers felt a great impact from the demand placed on them for supplying food to the army and navy. Farmer Randall Burroughes reports in his journal that he is dedicating the use of more and more land for planting oats and wheat.
The greatest strength of this book is Uglow’s extensive use of diaries, letters and journal entries that are woven throughout her narrative. William Harness, who is serving in the British navy, writes longingly to his wife and children whom he is away from for extended periods of time. He laments missing his children growing up and sharing in their childhood milestones. Bessy, his wife, writes him back tenderly with news of home and their blossoming brood of children.
Randall Burroughes, a tough but fair old farmer, keeps a detailed journal which catalogs weather patterns, crop rotations, farm workers, and soil conditions. He is the perfect example to remind the reader that, despite the fact that a global war is raging against the French, ordinary people are still farming their land, attending balls, gossiping and going to church.
In the Autumn of 1813, Uglow describes Napoleon’s defeat through the diary of John Oakes: “two Great Battles…at which The French and her Allies were totallyl routed, 30,000 taken Prisoner and 35,000 Killed & Sick taken. Bonaparte made his Escape wh. a party of Cavalry to Erfurt.” Political and military events are recorded in the diaries of British citizens alongside weather reports, births, deaths and other family news.
This book also gave me a better appreciation for some of my favorite books that are set in the 19th century. The chapter on “British Tars” chronicles in great detail the fear of the press gangs as they lurked around the British seaside looking for able bodied men to kidnap and force into naval service. This reminded me of the vivid scenes in Gaskell’s Silvia’s Lovers in which one of characters is taken off by a press gang and not heard from again for years. The discussions of the superior British navy and the opportunity for men to advance and get rich from prize money reminded me of Captain Wentworth in Austen’s Persuasion. In the chapters about the brief pause in the war, the Peace of Amiens, Uglow describes the extended travel vacations that were enjoyed by the aristocracy; in the summertime a favorite destination was the Lakes region of Britain which, of course, reminds us of Lizzie’s journey with her aunt and uncle through this part of the country and her accidental meeting with Darcy.
Some of the transitions between topics in different chapters were rather abrupt. A few times I became very interested in a particular story and the author would abruptly move on to another topic. For example, the chapter “Going to the Show,” which describes the elaborate celebrations for the Jubilee of King George III and the types of theatrical events staged during the war, ends with an odd and out of place description of Napoleon’s separation from Josephine.
Overall, this is a comprehensive tome that will be appreciated by a wide variety of readers. Those who take pleasure in British history, and social history in particular, will revel in the extensive use of primary source letters and journals. Those who are fans of Austen, Burney and Gaskell will enjoy learning more about the time period in which their favorite books are set. And finally, those who enjoy a well-written, thoroughly researched and interesting history will not want to miss reading IN THESE TIMES.
About The Author:
Jennifer Sheila Uglow OBE (née Crowther, born 1947) is a British biographer, critic and publisher. The editorial director of Chatto & Windus, she has written critically acclaimed biographies of Elizabeth Gaskell, William Hogarth, Thomas Bewick and the Lunar Society, among others, and has also compiled a women’s biographical dictionary.
This book alternates between two narratives, the first of which describes a pair of poor Irish immigrant orphans living on the streets of London in 1876 and who try to sell flowers in order to survive. Flora, who is 8, is crippled, and Rosie, who is 5, is blind and although they have wretched lives the one thing that they do have is each other. This part of the narrative is so pathetic and heart-wrenching that I almost gave up on the book because I could not take the sadness any longer.
Hazel Gaynor is an author and freelance writer in Ireland and the U.K. and was the recipient of the Cecil Day Lewis Award for Emerging Writers in 2012. Originally from North Yorkshire, England, she now lives in Ireland with her husband, two young children, and an accident-prone cat.
The Book Binder's Daughter 