Review: Tales of Arcadia by Stuart Shotwell

Since I enjoyed reading Edmund Persuader  and Tomazina’s Folly so much, I was thrilled to find that the author also published this collection of short stories. For those who are familiar with my reading habits, short stories are one of my favorite genres to review and I am very excited to write about this particular collection.

My Review:

Tales of ArcadiaThese short stories, as the title Tales of Arcadia suggests, are set against a simple, pleasurable and pastoral backdrop.  The setting especially resonates with me because it is redolent of rural New England where I currently reside.  The characters in these tales are humble people attempting to navigate their lives and experience the very connections that make us human: love, friendship, grief, infidelity and longing.

Stuart Shotwell’s writing genius lies in his ability to create characters who experience a variety of human relationships. Within these stories are examples of husbands and wives who cannot live without each other and whose love and mutual respect makes them better people.  But within these tales there is also a taste of marital life in which spouses are discontent, inattentive, withdrawn and selfish.

Stuart Shotwell reminds us that love is possible at any age and we always have the choice to extend our love to another person.  When a situation seems utterly hopeless, it is at these trying times that we must reach deep within ourselves, learn a lesson and become stronger through our struggles.  When something of ourselves is truly given from the heart, whether it be love, friendship or even a small gift, it is better than anything money can buy.

Even though I enjoyed the 10 short stories, the essays that begin and end the collection are my favorite pieces of writing.  The greatest desire of many authors is to accumulate vast wealth, to be at the top of every best seller list and to gain the status of celebrity with their publications.  Through practical lessons learned in his personal life that he applies to his work, the author recognizes that his writing, and the writings of any author, have the potential to affect a higher moral purpose and greater good both for his readers and for himself.

The author’s lesson about writing can even be applied to my little blog. I originally started this blog just for my own pleasure and to challenge myself to write better reviews and maybe share them with like-minded readers.  Sometimes I am frustrated when I see other bloggers with vast numbers of followers who review massed produced, pop culture books.  I have come to the conclusion that the most pleasurable and rewarding experiences that have resulted from my words are the connections I have made with readers and authors, even if it is only a select few.  Tales of Arcadia has reminded me that it is these human connections which bring the most meaning to my activities and to my life.

I have read a few so-called “best seller” novels and none have affected me nearly as much as Edmund Persuader, Tomazina’s Folly and Tales of Arcadia.  From the quality and depth of his writing it is evident that Stuart Shotwell’s novels and stories are a gift from the heart and are better than anything that money can buy.

A Few of My Favorite Quotes:

I usually do not quote from books that I review.  In fact, I don’t believe there is a single review on this blog that contains a quotation from a book.  But I am making an exception for these stories because so many of the beautifully written lines have lingered in my mind.

“If we know who we are and feel worthy in ourselves, we make the choices that are for the good of all.”  -from “Saul’s Road”

“This choice was in his power: the choice to believe in love, to love someone else, to try again.”  -from “Jack”

“Music, Clement thought, was as boundless as friendship itself–the more of yourself you gave to it, the more you found in yourself to give.” -from “Archon’s Gift”

“Open your basket, girl. What do you want to read?”  “I haven’t read Homer yet.”  “Then you haven’t read Greek.”  -from “Who Holds Thee?”

“And yet all we really have, when the dogmas and delusions are stripped away is one another: in our fellow humans and in our fellow creatures on earth lies our only sure source of meaning.” -from “The Lord’s Well”




Filed under Literary Fiction, Short Stories

4 responses to “Review: Tales of Arcadia by Stuart Shotwell

  1. I appreciated reading your personal reflections on reading and blogging choices, prompted by Stuart Shotwell’s essays in this story collection. Choices off the heavily trod paths make for such terrific discoveries–I love your enthusiasm for this author, and that makes me want to explore his books too. Thanks for these interesting surprises. I also agree heartily that the quality of personal connections makes all the difference. Since this is true in walking-around life, why shouldn’t the same be true of blogging, reviewing, tweeting, and facebooking? There are people behind the icons and the book covers! What a blessing to discover the real human discourse taking place in this amazing, abundant, virtual world.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you so much for your thoughtful comments, Lucy. I actually had someone like yourself in mind as far as making connections through my blog! You are always so supportive of my posts and I sincerely appreciate it!!! I highly recommend this author to you, I think you will enjoy all three of his works I have reviewed.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Ann

    I stopped by your blog today. I agree it’s amazing how many followers bloggers have when they review the “popular” books. I write reviews on books I have enjoyed and don’t get caught up with what the mainstream are doing. Great insight on your review.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s