And Then The Storm of Shit Begins: By Night in Chile by Roberto Bolaño

I got a true sense of the horror and brutality perpetrated by the Pinochet regime in Chile in a Comparative Politics class in college when I was assigned to read Jacobo Timerman’s book Chile: Death in the South. The most frightening and memorable parts of the book are the personal accounts of Chileans who were beaten and tortured under Pinochet’s reign of terror. The details of the horrific tortured described by these victims has stayed in my mind for 25 years. Timerman also reveals the strategies of ordinary Chileans to avoid being murdered, tortured or disappearing without a trace. I had this book in the back of my mind as I started to read Bolaño’s novella about a priest who lives through the overthrow of Allende’s socialist government and Pinocet’s seizure of power and implementation of a ruthless dictatorship.

Bolaño, who was himself imprisoned for a short time during Pinochet’s rule, takes a different approach towards describing, or not describing, the human suffering of totalitarianism. This brief story is told by a priest named Sebastian Urrutia Lacroix who is on his deathbed and no longer wishes to remain silent about what he has witnessed in his life: “One has to be responsible, as I have always said. One has a moral obligation to take responsibility for one’s actions, and that includes one’s words and silences, yes, one’s silences, because silences rise to heaven too….” Father Lacroix enters the seminary as a teenager and, in addition to his duties as a priest, becomes a prominent poet and literary critic in Chile.

Lacroix has access to the most prominent literary figures of the time including Pablo Neruda whom he meets at a weekend house party. The priest tells various stories about literary friends as well as himself. It’s remarkable that Bolaño not only uses a large variety of literary techniques in his narrative but he makes them flow mellifluously in such a short work. There are stories embedded within stories and Lacroix, as he is telling one of his longer tales, goes on for two or three pages in one long, uninterrupted sentence. For example, the priest takes an extensive tour of European churches and cathedrals in order to study the preservation of these buildings. He finds out that the greatest threat to these monuments are pigeons and priests throughout Europe have taken up falconry to deal with this menace:

…Fr. Pietro whistled and waved his arms and the shadow came down from the sky to the bell-tower and landed on the gauntlet protecting that Italian’s left hand, and then there wa no need to explain, for it was clear to me that the dark bird circling over the church of St. Mary of Perpetual Suffering was a falcon and Fr. Pietro had mastered the art of falconry, and that was the method they were using to rid the old church of pigeons, and then, looking down from the heights, I scanned the steps leading to the portico and the brick-paved square beside the magenta-coloured church, and in all that space, as hard as I looked, I could not see a single pigeon…

One of my favorite literary techniques that Bolaño uses is during a discussion between Lacroix and his mentor, a fellow literary critic, named Farewell. The anaphora employed throughout the conversation makes it appear more like a long-form poem then a dialogue. It’s also a good sampling of Bolaño’s erudite writing which alludes to authors ancient and modern:

And I: You have many years left to live, Farewell, And he: What’s the use, what use are books, they’re shadows, nothing but shadows. And I: Like the shadows you have been watching? And Farewell: Quite. And I: There’s a very interesting book by Plato on precisely that subject. And Farewell: Don’t be an idiot. And I: What are those shadows telling you, Farewell, what is it? And Farewell: They are telling me about the multiplicity of readings. And I: Multiple, perhaps, but thoroughly mediocre and miserable.

But what about Pinochet’s horrible regime and the horrors he inflicts on his fellow Chileans? I had expected something more gruesome, a work of fiction that would as detailed and honest as Timberman’s. But Lacroix, as he says in his opening words, has chosen to keep silent and his account of what takes place in Chile continues to be allusive throughout his deathbed remembrance. One has to pay careful attention to the hints he gives, like the mention of curfews throughout Santiago. Lacroix is recruited by Pinochet and his generals to give them a six week course on Marxism. The dictator and his men are kind to the priest and are good students, but he is riddled with guilt as to whether or not he did the right thing. Could he really have refused Pinochet’s request? Lacroix never says what could have happened to him if he refuses. He doesn’t even speculate. And a female author named Maria Canales holds a weekly literary saloon in her home despite curfews. Her writing is terrible and we can only assume that she is somehow connected to the regime in order to be allowed these privileges.

And so during Pinochet’s 14 year rule, Lacriox continues to read, and write poetry and criticism and only alludes to the vile parts of this dictatorship:

…my howling could only be heard by those who were able to scratch the surface of my writings with the nails of their index fingers, and they were not many, but enough for me, and life went on and on and on, like a necklace of rice grains, on each grain of which a landscape had been painted, tiny grains and microscopic landscapes, and I knew that everyone was putting that necklace on and wearing it, but no one had the patience or the strength or the courage to take it off and look at it closely and decipher each landscape grain by grain…

And what does this deathbed recognition of his continued silence in the midst of totalitarianism accomplish? Few details are given—no torture, rape, accounts of families disappearing in the middle of the night— but he only remarks that the “faces flash before my eyes at a vertiginous speed, the faces I admired, those I loved, hated, envied and despised. The face I protected, those I attacked, the face I hardened myself against and those I sought in vain.”

His concluding words do not sound like those of a man who has confessed his sins and is contrite: “And then the storm of shit begins.”


Filed under Spanish Literature

20 responses to “And Then The Storm of Shit Begins: By Night in Chile by Roberto Bolaño

  1. Great review. I tried to read this when my father was dying and could not focus. So I picked up a highly praised collection of Bolano’s stories instead. It had a couple of gems and a lot of sameness—not enough spark for me to understand what the fuss is about him. I should return to this one day though.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I would think that those allusions and hints are more powerful than graphic descriptions of torture from which readers may turn away. Your last quote certainly suggests that.

    One of my rare moments of pride in my country was in the ’90s when Jack Straw, our then Foreign Secretary, put Pinochet under house arrest.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. My favorite novels are when they are a leaning experience. But I confess, right about now I don’t think I can read about brutality. I can hardly get through the news.

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Bolano does sound dark – and I can often take dark, but I’m not sure whether I can right now. But what a killer last line!

    Liked by 2 people

  5. This was a good book.

    If you want more details, and a somewhat more direct approach to the subject, Bolaño’s novella Distant Star might do the trick. It is narrated by “Bolaño.” Personally, I would not expect much in the way of “honest” from Bolaño’s fiction. He is one of those other kinds of writers.


  6. This and Distant Star were my first two Bolanos – the latter was my favourite. Coincidentally, I’ve just read The Insufferable Gaucho (on the basis of reading books I’ve had since 2014) and was reminded how good Bolano can be. The title story is the best, but I must admit to enjoying ‘Police Rat a lot!’

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks so much for the suggestions. I hadn’t thought about trying his short fiction. I was thinking about reading more Bolaño in July for Stu’s Spanish Lit Month. Looking forward to it!


  7. Mike Huett

    Your review is powerful in itself, and I suspect an element of that comes from the lens of responsibility; do we have it in us to look and speak of oppression and murder, or do we play the games of wilful ignorance? We readers are not spared the dilemma, even if we are spared the lived experience. The “disappeared” are not erased by terminology, but by conscious effort.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Your writing both truly impresses and inspires me. I learn many things on many fronts, e.g., political history and the meaning of anaphora. So: Thanks a bunch.

    Liked by 2 people

  9. Kent

    I wonder if his reading/writing poetry & lit criticism while his compatriots were tortured in dark basements with the picana is rather the point. I’m reminded of those horrific smiling photos of Auschwitz guards and secretaries at the camp “picnic.” The banality of evil and all that.

    Interesting and perhaps relevant bit of trivia: “The device (the picana) was a notorious innovation introduced by police chief Polo Lugones, son of the famous poet and novelist Leopoldo Lugones.” Wikipedia

    Liked by 2 people

    • I was attempting to say that is Bolaño’s point. And there is an underlying criticism of the priest for being silent. Even on his deathbed he can’t come to terms with his silence.


  10. This book sounds really good, and yet I don’t think I could face reading it. The US-backed coup and murderous regime of Pinochet marked my student days, and tore the scales from my eyes. I read (won’t say enjoyed) Isabel Allende’s The House of the Spirits, a very powerful novel and it gave me the horrors forty years later. So much evil in some people. Thank you for the review, nonetheless.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s