Review: The Mapmaker’s Children by Sarah McCoy

I received an advanced review copy of this title from the publisher through TLC Book Tours.

My Review:
Mapmaker's ChildrenThis story is a dual narrative that traces the lives of two women: Sarah Brown is living in the 1860’s and her father is fighting to free slaves, and Eden Anderson is living in the 21st century and lays around wallowing in self-pity and thinking about her fertility issues.  The contrast between the characters of these two women and how they deal with hardships is extreme.  Sarah learns very early on that she cannot have children because of a high fever from dysentery, but she dedicates her life to her father’s cause of helping free slaves through the Underground Railroad.  Sarah draws maps so that these men and women who are desperate to escape their enslavement can make it to safety.  Even when Sarah’s father is hanged for his part in the Harper’s Ferry uprising, she bravely carries on the abolitionist cause at great personal risk.

Eden, on the other hand, is absorbed by anger and depression because she cannot have a child and she sadly takes her frustrations out on her husband.  When the story opens Eden is ready to give up on her marriage and move out.  The juxtaposition between the strength of Sarah and the weakness of Eden makes Eden an even more unlikeable character.  The eleven-year-old girl named Cleo who lives next door to Eden is a much more interesting and feisty character and both she and a dog named Cricket finally challenge Eden to stop feeling sorry for herself.

The two narratives gradually intersect as a secret door in the pantry of Eden’s house reveals the head of a doll.  With Cleo’s help Eden gets to the bottom of this mystery and she, predictably, learns some valuable lessons for her own life.

The strongest part of this novel is the story of Sarah Brown and her family as they fight for the abolition of slavery.  For me the story of Eden and her infertility were distracting and tiresome.  The events of the Harper’s Ferry Rebellion and the fight for freedom is such a powerful and interesting period of history and these events could stood on their own as the focus of an historical fiction novel.

I am interested to hear what other readers think: do you enjoy historical fiction novels with dual narratives in different time frames?

See what other bloggers are saying about the MAPMAKER’S CHILDREN book tour.  Click on the TLC banner below for a listing of all the stops on the tour.

About The Author:
McCoySARAH McCOY is the New York Times, USA Today, and international bestselling author of The Baker’s Daughter, a 2012 Goodreads Choice Award Best Historical Fiction nominee; the novella “The Branch of Hazel” in Grand Central; The Time It Snowed in Puerto Rico; and The Mapmaker’s Children (Crown, May 5, 2015).

Her work has been featured in Real Simple, The Millions, Your Health Monthly, Huffington Post and other publications. She has taught English writing at Old Dominion University and at the University of Texas at El Paso. She calls Virginia home but presently lives with her husband, an Army physician, and their dog, Gilly, in El Paso, Texas. Sarah enjoys connecting with her readers on Twitter at @SarahMMcCoy, on her Facebook Fan Page or via her website,



Filed under Historical Fiction

9 responses to “Review: The Mapmaker’s Children by Sarah McCoy

  1. Interesting, Melissa – I haven’t yet read this book but did recently complete “The Baker’s Daughter.” The author did a dual narrative there as well, and I much preferred the story of Elsie (WWII) to that of Reba (present day El Paso). I’d have liked a story about Elsie on its own.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I do enjoy the dual time frame, especially when both stories are strong! For me, “Possession” by A. S. Byatt is probably my favorite example, because it was also literary fiction, a novel of academia, and a bit of mystery too! Byatt is, of course, a rare genius, a master (or mistress) of the craft. Although it was a bit hokey, I really had fun reading “The Eight” by Katherine Neville–the two stories and voices were so different. Glad that you liked at least one of the story threads in this new book.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I live only a few hours from Harper’s Ferry so I’m familiar with John Brown’s story, though I haven’t heard much about his daughter. It sounds like quite an interesting tale!

    Thanks for being a part of the tour.


  4. Pingback: Book Tour & Review: The Mapmaker's Children by Sarah McCoy - FictionZeal

  5. Melissa, Interesting thoughts, but I think you’re a little tough on Eden. Even you write “… she’s absorbed in anger and depression.” Infertility and depression are some pretty difficult issues. For what it’s worth … Cindy


    • I have had two people very close to me suffer from infertility and depression as a result of many, many rounds of medical treatments The character of Eden could have been so much more interesting, especially when dealing with her infertility. The supporting characters, including the dog, were more fascinating than Eden.


  6. Pingback: TLC Book Review & Giveaway: The Mapmaker’s Children by Sarah McCoy | Books in the Burbs

  7. Pingback: Sarah McCoy, author of The Mapmaker’s Children, on tour April – June 2015 | TLC Book Tours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s