I have to admit that I was drawn to this book because of its autobiographical aspect. Having just lately read quite a bit of Virginia Woolf’s extensive and varied forms of writing, I was curious to get a glimpse into her personal life with her husband. Published in 1914, Woolf began to compose this biting satire of English life in the early 20th century on his honeymoon. Harry Davis, the male protagonist in the novel who thinks he is very different from the other young people that live in his London suburb, is a harsher and more cantankerous version of Woolf himself. Harry has just moved outside of London to Richstead with his parents and his younger sister Hetty. Upon their arrival the Davis family is invited over by their new neighbors, The Garlands—four unmarried, virgin young women and their widowed mother. Harry hates everything about their ordered and conventional life and these women view Harry as a discontented man whose behavior is strange and sullen.
Harry is restless and the last thing he wants to do is settle down with one of the virgins he meets in the suburbs and live a boring, formulaic life as a husband, father and businessman. He reads deep, philosophical novels, he paints and he prefers to spend his time with other interesting people. His painting at a local studio causes him to come in contact with a woman named Camilla Lawrence who is believed to be based on Virginia Woolf. Camilla, unlike the Garlands, is urbane, sophisticated, educated and aloof. Harry visits Camilla, her sister Katharine and their father and engages in witty conversation with people whom he feels are his equals. Harry’s interactions with her make him contemplate the meaning of love and how one falls into it. Camilla’s lack of mutual desire or interest in Harry is, at times, a harsh portrayal of Leonard and Virginia Woolf’s own courtship. Harry’s thoughts about love are depressing and confused:
It seemed ridiculous that one human being could affect another human being like this. Love? Was it all imagination, a fantastic dream of this absurd little animal, man? It was impossible at moments to believe that he felt anything for Camilla at all. After all, what had he asked of her? To say: ‘I love you.’ Would that have thrown him into ecstasies—for twelve hours, or at most, to judge from what seemed best among others, for a few hours spread over twelve months.
Even though he has fallen in love, Harry continues to mock people like the Garlands and when Gwen, the youngest daughter, asks to borrow one of Harry’s books he has some harsh opinions of her and the other virgins in Richstead:
Harry did not forget to send Dostoevsky’s Idiot to Gwen, and he laughed to himself not unkindly as he handed it to the Garlands’ maid. He was putting strong wine into the mouth of a babe with a vengeance. He hoped it would not completely upset her digestion, yet he had not much compunction if it should make her feel a little uncomfortable, because, after all, that was what in his opinion these virgins of Richstead really needed—something to show them that life was not all Richstead, virginity and vicars, needlework and teas. And when he had said ‘For Miss Gwen, please,’ he did not give very much thought to her or The Idiot.
In the end, however, Harry’s arrogance causes him to be hoisted with his own petard. A comment that Mr. Lawrence makes to Harry is rather fitting for his tragic fate in the novel: Video meliora proboque, deteriora sequor (I see better things and approve of them, but I follow worse things–Ovid, Met. 7.20) The ending was quite a surprise for me and I won’t give it away but I will say that the title of Woolf’s novel is both ironic and sarcastic. I highly recommend this book to those who are interested in taking a peek at Woolf’s mindset while he was on his honeymoon with Virginia.
6 responses to “Video Meliora Proboque, Deteriora Sequor: The Wise Virgins by Leonard Woolf”
Wonder if the name Lawrence was significant; there seems a touch of Bert & Frieda in Harry & Camilla.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I wonder. I haven’t read anything about the significance of the names he chose. Interesting to think about.
I have not yet read VW’s Night & Day but I gather it is about her courtship with Leonard.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m also curious to read The Voyage Out because it was written at the same time as this one.
VO is an interesting, weird, not entirely successful novel. It has some strange, almost surreal moments. And it includes a cameo by a much younger Clarissa Dalloway. I taught it once and the students found it tough sledding. Certainly not where I would start with Woolf but definitely worth it for those who have delved into her later work.
I really think Jacob’s Room is a super amazing and underrated early Woolf novel.
Fascinating review Melissa – I have yet to read this one, but I really think I should get Leonard’s viewpoint. As for VO, I was a little underwhelmed when I first read it decades ago (immediately after having been swept away by Mrs. Dalloway). However, on re-reading I got a lot more out of it and you can see the seeds of what was to come.